Update: Racial and Climate Justice for Point Molate
By Courtney Cummings, Richmond resident, Native American Activist and steering committee member of the Point Molate Alliance, and David Helvarg, Director of Blue Frontier, an Ocean Conservation group, and steering committee member of the Point Molate Alliance.
May 15, 2022.
The public is still fighting for Point Molate. According to Andres Soto, longtime community activist in Richmond, “Selling beautiful public land for a luxury development is not justice for a community of color.”
Given the ongoing crisis of the COVID-19 pandemic, the current economic collapse, the persistent virus of American racism, and the climate emergency, many people are looking at land development choices in a new light. The fight to Save the East Bay’s Point Molate and to keep this 411-acre public headland in public hands is, like many land use decisions, also about institutional racism and environmental justice.
When it comes to racial equity, no one can seriously doubt that if Richmond, California, a poor community of color, were a wealthy white community, this last unprotected natural headland on San Francisco Bay would have long ago been set aside as a regional park and visitor destination.
Instead, it was almost sold off for a casino complex until the people voted overwhelmingly against that. Now it’s part of a wider plan to privatize the city’s shoreline for high-end luxury housing, while the city center and other areas with existing infrastructure and transportation have little housing for today’s residents.
Mostly because of the costs of infrastructure for the isolated and undeveloped land between a bridge and an oil refinery, new homebuyers at Point Molate would require incomes of around $250,000 to buy into the planned development of up to 2050 units, according to the city’s own fiscal analysis.
In contrast, Richmond’s average household income is about $70,000. This huge disparity reflects a national wealth gap between white families and families of color including a history of economic discrimination in home loans and banking that has targeted African-Americans.
Historically Point Molate’s beach served as a place where Black residents could escape segregation. Today, Point Molate Beach Park continues to be used primarily by families of color and more recently by parents with children looking for a safe and natural setting to take their kids during the COVID-19 lockdown.
But SunCal, the southern California developer looking to buy Point Molate, has released plans to locate a sewage pumping station where the beach parking lot is now located!
Fishing on the headland is another tradition for a multi-generational community of Black and Latinx fishermen and their families, but scientists warn that the SunCal development will ruin the near shore eelgrass habitat.
Point Molate is also home to multiple sacred shell mounds of the Ohlone people. But today’s Ohlone were not consulted in the Draft Environmental Impact Report put out by the developer and approved by the previous City Council. That City Council also approved $900,000 (now $1,010,000) for a Sacramento-based corporate law firm to defend the widely challenged impact report. Point Molate is also the site of a historic 19th century Chinese fish camp that has been partly exposed by coastal erosion linked to sea level rise.
When it comes to the climate emergency, bad local land use decisions are a major driver of the problem. Point Molate is home to rare California native plants and animals including a California grassland watershed to be bulldozed by SunCal. It has one of the two highest concentrations of nesting Ospreys in the Bay Area, also the Bay’s most pristine eelgrass beds, home to herring and striped bass, leopard sharks, bat rays, sea hares, Dungeness crab, and more.
There are over 600 identified species of plants and animals at Point Molate that play a vital role in both reducing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere and contributing to human health. Protecting nature, science has shown, is one of the surest ways to address climate as well as prevent pandemics.
The people of Richmond have overwhelmingly expressed their support for a public park at Point Molate through hearings, testimony, protest, survey and petition. A planned ballot measure was derailed by the pandemic lockdown.
Despite the rush to ink an agreement to sell off Point Molate before November’s election, Richmond citizens deserve a chance to speak out against racism and environmental destruction and for a better future by continuing to elect new city council members, including candidates committed to Saving Point Molate and to keeping our public lands in well-washed hands.